NEWSLINE - Fall 2000
Study Tour Provides an Inside Look
at Japanese Economy and Culture
Japan plays an important role in the world economy, and as a major U.S.
trading partner. Yet most U.S. business schools have not adequately
reflected this in their courses and faculty research activities. So at a
time when recent political shifts make it more critical than ever to understand
Japanese business practices, American business school faculty and graduates
remain relatively unsophisticated in their knowledge of the Asian powerhouse and
how it operates.
"In U.S. education we have been tempted to discuss Asian economies as a
whole, as a parallel to the European Union, and this has caused much confusion
among our students," said Pat Cantrell, associate professor at the College
of Business Administration, University of Central Arkansas.
"This is not a world in which we've done business. We are all just
learning," added Daniel E. Costello, dean of the College of Business at
Colorado State University.
To help close this gap in understanding, AACSB has, since 1994, teamed with
the Keizai Koho Center (KKC), a leading Japanese business organization, to offer
an annual study tour to Japan for U.S. business school faculty and
administrators. The 12-day program is designed to stimulate curricular
change at the participants' institutions and to provide opportunities for
comparative research.
To learn about Japan's economy and business climate, the group visits
businesses and industries where they observe the Japanese economy in
action. They also participate in discussions with top executives and
attend seminars with Japanese academics.
"We firmly believe that the Japan Study Tour has helped AACSB member
institutions to integrate a Japanese dimension into their teaching, curriculum
development and research," said John J. Fernandes, AACSB president and
chief executive officer. "A number of deans have mentioned to me personally
how wonderful their experience was and how much they appreciated the KKC's
contribution."
"We would like to express our appreciation to AACSB for continuously
supporting the Japan Study Tour over the past years," said Masami Tashiro,
KKC senior director. "The Keizai Koho Center highly values its
relationship with AACSB and welcomes the opportunity to work with such an
influential organization."
Eleven people took part in last June's tour, which focused on e-commerce and
Japanese and U.S. management styles. The group visited the headquarters of
organizations such as Toyota Motor Corporation, Matsushita Electric Industrial
Co., Ltd. (Panasonic), Misumi Corporation, NTT DoCoMo, Inc. and the American
Chamber of Commerce in Japan. They also met with representatives of the
Ministry of International Trade and Industry (MITI); Bank of Japan; Sun
Microsystems; Tokyo University; Matsui Securities Co., Ltd.; NEC Corporation;
Bridgestone Corporation; Ito-Yokada, Co., Ltd. and others.
"We were amazed by the technological advancements and the vitality of
the businesses we visited," said Cantrell, tour participant.
Costello added that the tour "provided us with an understanding of the
Japanese economy from the perspectives of the past, present and future.
The current economic challenges were seen as a result of changes in the global
business infrastructure. For Japan to stay competitive, many domestic
reforms were identified." He added that "learning to see
business strategies from the Japanese perspective was extremely
worthwhile."
Debra J. Cohen, associate professor, School of Business and Public
Management, George Washington University, added, "The combination of
speakers and company visits allowed us to gain an understanding of a multitude
of Japanese business issues."
A presentation at Sun Microsystems, for example, summarized the Japanese
economy over the last decade, including the effects of Japanese financial policy
and corporate governance. The AACSB/KKC group learned about the Japanese
emphasis on a networked society, with management based on human rather than
financial resources. They also heard about changes in industrial
structure, the financial and accounting reforms expected, and the support
rationales for these reforms.
The visit to Toyota provided opportunities to observe assembly-line
operations where human beings work together wit robotics and to inspect and
drive futuristic prototype vehicles.
"I particularly enjoyed the tour of the Toyota facility," said
Brian F. O'Neil, professor and director of graduate business programs in the
School of Business at Clarkson University. "The opportunity to see
first hand the assembly operations was fantastic. I very much look forward
to using the experience in the classroom," he said. "Also,
having the chance to ride in two state-of-the-art vehicles was very much
appreciated."
At Matsushita Electric, the tour included the Hall of Science and Industry,
which is filled with products that have not been introduced to the market or
have been introduced only in Japan. Since the Japanese market is aging,
Matsushita emphasizes design elements geared to an older population.
The government's role in supply chain management and coordination of
standards was presented at MITI, where industry leaders participated in
discussion.
A production facility staffed primarily by handicapped workers was what the
group saw at the Omron Kyoto Sun Industries plant. Of the 206 production
workers, 149 are handicapped. The severely handicapped live on the plant
site in dormitories.
The group especially enjoyed the presentation by the Ito-Yokada, Co. Ltd.,
which operates Seven-Eleven Japan retail stores. They learned about the
adaptation of the superstore concept to meet the high service and quality
expectations of the Japanese consumers and the strategy of using convenience
stores as part of an e-commerce sales strategy. "Gradually we
recognized the usefulness of frequent trips to the convenience stores because of
the lack of storage space [in homes]. The intersection of social,
technological and economic trends was pronounced," reported Karen A.
Froelich, assistant professor of management, College of Business Administration,
North Dakota State University.
Visits to dot.com entrepreneurs were a highlight of the trip.
"These innovative global businesses and developers of the third- and
fourth-generation Internet technologies spoke of a future world of international
markets and unlimited applications," Cantrell said.
The group was surprised to learn that Japanese regulations prohibit many
industries from creating cyber-malls. "The law still requires hard
copy paper confirmation of orders, outlines of corporate policies, etc.,"
said Frederick Anthony Palumbo, associate professor, Sy Syms School of Business
at Yeshiva University. "But the policy is changing, and Internet
transactions will be permitted by 2003."
An inspiring session focusing on Japan's technological movement into the 21st
century was held at NTT DoCoMo, Inc., where the group learned about the fusion
of telecommunications and the Internet. The company's I-mode technology is
essentially an extremely small cellular phone weighing about two ounces.
From this phone a person can see the Internet and conduct banking, make travel
arrangements and entertainment reservations and send and receive Email. To
date, this technology is available only in Japan, where in 16 months the number
of I-mode subscribers grew from zero to 7.5 million. "While some of
the things they are doing are being done elsewhere, the diffusion of technology
into the Japanese marketplace is truly amazing," said Eric James Burton,
dean of the College of Business at Middle Tennessee State University.
All along the way, the tour participants made comparisons between the
Japanese and U.S. economies, sometimes with surprising conclusions.
"One of the main results of the experience was the recognition of the many
areas in which Japan is a more advanced economy than the U.S., and a
clarification of the mutual economic interests of the two countries,: Cantrell
said. "In U.S. education, we have tended to focus on the rapid
development of the 'Asian Tiger' economies rather than the absolute achievement
levels of the Japanese economy. This tour showed us that Japan is not just
another Pacific Rim economy but rather a society equal to or superior to the
U.S."
At the conclusion of this year's tour, participants were enthusiastic about
taking what the had learned back to their institutions.
"What I had read about the Japanese management style and what I was told
during this trip was the real situation will definitely affect how I discuss
this topic in the classroom," said Ellen J. Frank, professor and director
of the Global Center at Southern Connecticut State University's School of
Business. "My grasp of international finance and its trends in the
future has increased. I can foresee much more interesting lectures in my
International Business course."
"My dean has requested a course in the Economy of Japan and, given the
abundance of materials and experiences with the Keizai Koho Center, this will be
a possibility in the near future. This experience has motivated me to
increase communication with Japan experts on our campus in art, language and
history," said Cantrell.
Nachum Sicherman, associate professor at Columbia University's Graduate
School of Business, foresaw using Matsui Securities as an example of "how
dramatic changes in barriers to entry can totally change an industry even in a
conservative place like Japan."
Middle Tennessee's Burton said the tour would be most helpful as he
interfaced with the Japan Program on campus and with the Japan Society of
Tennessee, with which the university is affiliated. The experience gave
him "a much improved understanding of the cultural differences that
influence how business is done both in Japan and the U.S." It also
provided "a deeper appreciation of the richness of the Japanese
culture," he said
Several members of the group found their curiosity aroused for future study
and travel. Debra Cohen wants to learn more about the Japanese culture and
to explore Japanese human resource management issues. "I have already
begun revising some of my teaching materials and approaches in my International
Human Resource Management course to incorporate what I have learned," she
said.
"At CU we will sponsor initiatives that include Japan," said Donald
L. Stevens, professor, assistant vice chancellor for academic affairs and
director of the Institute for International Business at the University of
Colorado at Denver. "Our International Executive Roundtable will
include Japan speakers; I will discuss with faculty the inclusion of Japanese
topics in the Faculty Development in International Business workshops that we
sponsor each June. I will raise the possibility of a Japan study tour for
our Executive MBA program and propose adding a Japan site to our undergraduate
study tour program." He added that his experience on the AACSB/KKC
tour would affect the agenda he sets for the Institute for International
Business.
North Dakota State's Froelich said her experience would have an immediate
impact on courses in money and banking, intermediate macroeconomics, and
strategic management. She is planning to share information and materials
with colleagues on her own campus and, more broadly, in a consortium of local
universities. "Longer-term impacts include continuation of a research
project examining the coverage of the Japanese economy in business school
curriculums in the U.S.," said Froelich. "Further, I will work
through the curriculum committee to achieve greater coordination of content
between the existing international business electives and required courses in
order to improve coverage of Japan."
Michael G. Tearney, associate dean of academic affairs and director of
international programs at the Gatton College of Business and Economics at the
University of Kentucky, said he would integrate much of what he learned and saw
into his accounting lectures. "Of particular importance is the
information on corporate governance and disclosure," he said. Tearney
also plans to develop an international accounting course, in which much of what
he learned on the tour would be "invaluable."
Upon his return, Colorado State's Costello shared the information he gained
on Japan's e-business with colleagues who teach international business. He
also taught a distance-learning session on the Japanese economy to 450 MBA
students in 50 states and 11 countries. He was asked to provide assistance
in the planning of Denver Mayor Willington Webb's fall economic development trip
to Japan and to talk about the Japanese economy at a university-wide fall
forum. In addition, Costello is exploring opportunities for a CSU Denver
Executive MBA trip to Japan and plans to encourage students to take study-abroad
programs there.
Cantrell was confident that the trip met its objectives: "The program is
extraordinary. I believe it will prove very successful in convincing the
business educator, and in turn the business student in the U.S., of the unique
importance of Japan in the global economy and of accurately informing them about
the social and economic goals of the Japanese people."
Kentucky's Tearney added, "The AACSB/KKC 2000 Japan Study Tour was the
singularly most outstanding faculty development activity I have ever been
fortunate enough to attend. I learned more in a shorter period of time
about the Japanese approach to capitalism, the severity of the 1990s recession
in Japan, cultural differences between Japanese and Americans, and the general
beauty of the Japanese countryside and people than I ever thought
imaginable."
|