|
 |
NEWSLINE - Fall 1998
AACSB/KKC
Study Tour to Japan Promotes Learning, Stirs Curricular Change
The annual study tour to Japan, sponsored by
AACSB and the Keizai Koho Center, a leading Japanese business organization,
continues to reap reports that the experience has had a profound effect on those
deans, associate deans, department chairs and faculty members selected to
participate. The program aims to stimulate curricular change at institutions
whose representatives participate in the tour and to provide opportunities to
pursue comparative research activities.
The 1998 tour, themed "Understanding
Japanese Business: Japan in Transition," brought 14 representatives from a
variety of AACSB member schools to Japan in June where they spent 12 days
visiting Japanese companies, holding discussions with top management and
officials of the business community, attending seminars with Japanese academics,
meeting with the American Chamber of Commerce in Japan, and engaging directly
with government officials and university faculty. The breadth of activities,
visits and presentations at companies such as Mazda Motor Corporation,
Mitsubishi Heavy Industries and Omron Kyoto Japan Sun Industries, as well as
experiences with Japanese culture, tradition and people, proved to be tour
highlights.
"The company visits were an excellent
opportunity to meet a wide range of Japanese companies and learn about their
strategy, corporate governance and practices," said John Kraft, business
dean at the University of Florida and a tour participant. "The visits
provided a solid understanding of Japanese management style and practice. We all
obtained a keen appreciation of the Japanese management style, which is both
cautious and deliberate."
A major focus of the 1998 tour was focusing on
reforms of Japan and the issue of corporate governance, which is undergoing a
transition there. "Traditional Japanese management policies include
lifetime employment, in-house labor unions, the seniority system and quotas to
maintain a share of the market," said John Doering, associate professor at
the University of Wisconsin-Green Bay. "These policies are inconsistent
with global standards and Japanese management recognizes that it must be
restructured to improve performance and become more globally responsive. There
is evidence that Japanese companies are beginning to make the necessary
changes," he said.
Doering said he believes changes in corporate
governance will require widespread changes in other institutions in Japan, as
well. "For example, without lifetime employment, employees will need
portable skills that will make them attractive to other employers," he
said. "Rather than a set of company-specific skills, workers will need a
broader knowledge base that can be more easily transferred to other businesses.
As a result, Japanese universities will need to develop business education and
MBA programs to facilitate the transition of managers between industries."
Doering pointed to the Japanese pension system as another area needing reform in
order to accommodate the relocation of workers, stating "At the present
time, pensions are not portable." These examples illustrate that the
changes are systematic and are not merely confined to principles of corporate
governance, said Doering.
"The Japanese business model has much to
commend," said Frances L. Ayres, professor and director of the School of
Accounting at the University of Oklahoma. "They have a stable, hard working
work force, high quality products and well-developed manufacturing and
distribution processes. At the same time, they are impaired by a structure that
makes some types of change difficult. Hope- fully, in the long run, a new
business model will evolve that combines the best of Japanese and Western
business practices," she said.
Tour participants said they also learned about a
number of social differences and trends. "The program reemphasized for me
how relationship-based Japanese social interaction is," said Eric
Abrahamson, associate professor in the School of Business at Columbia
University. "It also sensitized me to how Japanese social relations can be
simultaneously centralized and decentralized. I also was surprised by the
Japanese fondness, as in the U.S., for all types of fads - including management
fads and what was described as the corporate governance fad."
For some, visiting Japanese universities was
valuable. "While some very productive research is conducted in Japan,
language continues to be a big barrier in the spread of knowledge from Japan to
the West," said Peggy Keiko Takahashi, assistant business professor at the
University of San Francisco. "Moreover, Japanese research in business tends
to have a more qualitative feel than U.S. research. My hope is that the tour
will lead to some fruitful joint research projects in the future."
Takahashi said that studying the curriculum at other universities also gave her
a better sense of how the program at her school compares to international
programs.
Institutions of the tour participants stand to
benefit in numerous ways. "I believe I will be more effective in the
classroom with executives and MBA students," said James R. Freeland,
associate dean and business professor, Darden Graduate School of Business
Administration, University of Virginia. "My perspective has been broadened
and I have gained more understanding of Japanese business. I certainly am a more
informed observer of Japan." Others point to their plans for updating the
curriculum, expanding student and faculty exchanges with Japan, establishing
student internships, collaborating on programs or activities with area studies
centers on their own campuses, and making presentations and writing articles
about their trip. "The Japan Study Tour was a wonderful experience that
will reap benefits for years to come in terms of teaching, research and
curriculum development," said Oklahoma's Ayres. "I plan to continue to
learn and to study more about Japan in the future and, hopefully, to
return."
The 1998 study tour participants also included:
Linda Delene, professor, Western Michigan University; Adele Curran Foley,
associate dean and director of MBA programs, Saint Joseph's University; Taggart
Frost, associate professor, University of Northern Iowa; Michele V.Gee,
assistant professor, University of Wisconsin-Parkside; Diana Lawson, associate
professor, University of Maine; Barbara H. Nemecek, dean, Montana State
University at Billings; Aleda Marie Roth, associate professor, University of
North Carolina at Chapel Hill; and William L. Sartoris, professor and chair of
international activities, Indiana University.
A brochure concerning the 1999 Study Tour, which
begins June 6, 1999, and ends on June 17, 1999, was mailed to AACSB member deans
in October. Program directors, associate deans, deans, department chairs and
faculty who lead or influence curriculum development at AACSB member schools are
encouraged to apply. An application form was included with the brochure and also
is available on the AACSB Web site. Application deadline is December 30, 1998. A
selection committee made up of representatives of AACSB and the Keizai Koho
Center will choose the 1999 tour participants. Candidates will be advised of the
results of the selection process no later than February 24, 1999.
|